Skip to content

Arnarchy Web

The Web Without Any Rules

How to Choose Home Insurance That Fits Your Property and Budget?

The surcharge for natural disasters applied to home insurance policies increased from 12% to 20% of the relevant premium on 1 January 2025.…

Femme consultant des documents d'assurance immobilière sur une table en bois dans une cuisine moderne

The natural disaster surcharge applied to home insurance policies increased from 12% to 20% of the relevant premium on January 1, 2025. This increase changes the base cost of all property insurance, regardless of the optional coverage selected. Choosing a suitable policy therefore means looking beyond a simple price comparison and examining what each line of coverage actually protects against, given the risks specific to the property’s address.

Climate risks by address: what the policy covers and excludes

A comprehensive home insurance policy includes natural disaster coverage, but this coverage is triggered only when an interministerial order recognizes a state of natural disaster for the municipality and the event in question. Without this recognition, no natural disaster compensation applies, even if the damage is real and documented.

Clay soil shrink-swell is a case in point. A detached house built on clay soil may develop structural cracks after a period of drought. Compensation will be paid only if the municipality is officially classified as a natural disaster area for that specific event. We recommend checking the clay soil maps available on Géorisques before signing or renewing a policy.

The expert assessment process for drought damage also changed in 2025. Checking the policy’s terms and conditions on this specific point helps you anticipate applicable time frames and deductibles. Statutory natural disaster deductibles vary depending on the cause of the damage, particularly in the case of drought, where they remain higher than for other perils.

Before signing, check the property’s address against the municipality’s natural risk prevention plans (PPRN). If the home is in an exposed area without an approved PPRN, some insurers apply surcharges or specific exclusions that you should look for in the policy schedule.

Couple discussing a home insurance offer with an advisor in a modern apartment

Deductibles and compensation limits in home insurance

Comparing annual premiums alone can hide the true cost of a claim. Two policies with the same premium can leave you with very different out-of-pocket costs, depending on the deductible and coverage limits. To assess the actual protection offered, compare three factors across policies using Catherine Immo’s insurance or another well-structured comparison site:

  • The deductible per claim: whether it is a fixed amount or a percentage, it determines what the policyholder pays out of pocket. A lower deductible increases the premium, while a higher deductible reduces the cost but leaves you more exposed in the event of water damage or theft
  • The contents coverage limit: if set too low, it leaves part of your belongings uninsured. The declared value should reflect the actual replacement cost, not a rough estimate
  • The compensation basis (new-for-old or with depreciation deducted): a difference of several hundred euros for the same claim can result from this single factor, which is often relegated to an appendix of the policy

Your monthly budget should not be the only factor guiding your choice. A cheaper policy with a €500 deductible for water damage will cost you more than a slightly more expensive policy with a €150 deductible from the first claim.

Coverage to check based on your status: owner, tenant or landlord

The minimum required coverage differs depending on your occupancy status. Tenants must take out at least tenant liability coverage for fire, explosion and water damage. Owner-occupiers are not legally required to have insurance unless they live in a condominium, but going without coverage exposes them to significant financial risk.

Condominium owner

The law requires the condominium association to have collective liability insurance. This insurance does not cover the interior of an individual unit. Owners must take out separate comprehensive home insurance to protect their belongings, fixtures and personal liability.

Non-occupying landlord

Landlords should consider taking out non-occupant owner insurance (PNO). It provides cover when a property is vacant or if the tenant lets their own policy lapse. Rent guarantee insurance, often offered as an optional extra, is a separate policy and does not replace PNO coverage.

Furnished rental or mobility lease tenant

A mobility lease (1 to 10 months) does not exempt tenants from the insurance requirement. Some insurers offer flexible-term policies suited to this type of lease, with monthly pricing. Checking that theft coverage includes the landlord’s furniture is an important detail that is often overlooked.

Man filling out an online property insurance form in a home office

Home insurance renewal: checks you should not put off

Automatic renewal carries over the same coverage and limits. If the property has changed (renovations, an extension or the purchase of valuable items), the renewed policy may no longer provide enough coverage without the policyholder realizing it until a claim is made.

Updating the declared contents value at every renewal is the simplest way to avoid being undercompensated. The same applies to outdoor features (patio, conservatory, garden shed), which are not always included in the basic coverage.

The law allows you to cancel a home insurance policy at any time after the first year, with no fees or penalties. This flexibility makes annual renegotiation a realistic option: comparing policies when you receive your renewal notice, while factoring in the natural disaster surcharge increase to 20%, gives you an accurate picture of the policy’s true cost.

  • Check that the declared floor area matches the home’s actual floor area
  • Make sure outbuildings (cellar, garage, parking space) are included in the insured property
  • Check that climate-related exclusions have not been changed by an endorsement since the policy was last taken out

The right home insurance policy is not the one that costs the least to take out, but the one where your out-of-pocket costs after a claim remain manageable. Comparing price, deductible, coverage limits and exclusions against the property’s actual address and exposure to natural hazards remains the most reliable way to choose between two policies.

How to Choose Home Insurance That Fits Your Property and Budget?